Well, I guess the battle is over as far as the state of Washington is concerned. Following is an email we received from them, and it looks like the course of action they have taken is to do nothing. We are disabling the form to email them, because it obviously is a moot point by now. Amazon has stated that it will carry books from non-BookSurge publishers as long as the author sends a minimum of five copies to Amazon for inventory. So I suppose that is a compromise, and it's probably about as good as we're going to do. But we still encourage you to use the form in the previous post below to email the Dept. of Justice in Washington. Will they do anything? Doubtful. But we might as well keep yelling and see if anybody listens.
Here is the email:
Dear Mr. Work:
The Washington Attorney General’s Antitrust Division has received many complaints regarding the new “print on demand” or “POD” policy recently implemented by Amazon.com. We want to thank all of those who have brought this matter to our attention and who have provided information and insight into the questions. We appreciate the concerns that have been expressed.
We have reviewed each of these complaints and we have contacted Amazon to explore the concerns that have been raised. Amazon responded to our inquiry by directing us to a publicly posted “Open Letter to Interested Parties” in which they describe their new policy.
The “Open Letter to Interested Parties” is posted on the Internet at http://phx.corporate-ir.net/phoenix.zhtml?c=176060&p=irol-printondemand. Some of the complaints that we have received state that Amazon is refusing to sell books printed by Lightning Source or other POD publishers, and will only sell POD books printed by BookSurge. In its “Open Letter to Interested Parties”, Amazon addresses this question:
Do I need to switch completely to having my POD titles printed at Amazon?
No, there is no request for exclusivity. Any publisher can use Amazon's POD service just for those units that ship from Amazon and continue to use a different POD service provider for distribution through other channels.
Alternatively, you can use a different POD service provider for all your units. In that case, we ask that you pre-produce a small number of copies of each title (typically five copies), and send those to us in advance (Amazon Advantage Program-successfully used by thousands of big and small publishers). We will inventory those copies. That small cache of inventory allows us to provide the same rapid fulfillment capability to our customers that we would have if we were printing the titles ourselves on POD printing machines located inside our fulfillment centers. Unlike POD, this alternative is not completely "inventoryless." However, as a practical matter, five copies is a small enough quantity that it is economically close to an inventoryless model.
The complaints that we have received have come from across the country. It appears that the markets involved are national in scope. Thus, it may be more appropriate to refer this matter to one of the federal antitrust agencies for review.
For these reasons, and based on the information that has been provided to us, the Attorney General’s office does not plan further action on this matter. However, and as noted before, this is not a conclusive legal opinion and anyone feeling that they have been harmed and wish to pursue a remedy should consider consulting with private counsel.
If you have additional information or have evidence that what Amazon is representing is not true, please feel free to contact us.
Sincerely,
Brady Johnson
Assistant Attorney General
Antitrust Division
Washington State
Office of Attorney General
Thursday, April 24, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
20 comments:
Even though I was the first to suggest this idea, I never thought the Washington State AG would actually take legal action. Politics and business in Seattle is as corrupt as in Chicago. The son of the city's mayor was recently caught in a multi-million dollar scam and no one was particularly surprised.
Contacting the AG was simply putting bit of pressure on the system and generating a bit of news. It was a way to make Bezos pay attention to this. Now we have their attention. Now we need to get tough.
Forget supplying Amazon with five copies and paying an annual fee for the dubious privilege of adding to their profits. That's not a viable option. Anyone who does so is likely to find the ante soon upped.
They have some ten shipping centers, all of which will need to be stocked if their Prime shipping scheme is to work. Do you want the hassle of keep an inventory of five books for each title you have in each of their ten centers?
If you have fifty titles, that's an inventory of of 2500 books that have been printed and paid for without you getting a penny in income, as well as 2500 physical books you have to track, less Amazon ship them but not pay you. That sort of hassle and expense is not what we got into pod for. Besides, from what I hear, Amazon will nickel and dime you to death on this, sending a request for one book on Monday, a request for two different titles on Wednesday etc. Remember, you're soaking the cost of all this. They have no reason to play nice with you. Amazon isn't nice. Live with that.
Besides, legally books are not like most other products. It's quite likely that offering that service to Amazon, but no other bookstore, online or otherwise, is illegal. Want to also get forced to pay and supply B&N or Powell or any bookstore that decides to keep a few of your books in inventory? You will, if you sign with Amazon and one of them takes you to court, that is, after you pay their legal costs. And Amazon is likely to hire high-powered lawyers who will get them off scott-free while you're the criminal. After all, it was your fault for accepting an offer from them that you didn't immediately offer to others. And do you want to have to supply book files in some quirky format to every fly-by-night combo pod/online store that comes along? By law, what you do for one bookseller, you have to do for all.
No, we must take charge of this dispute. Do nothing and we loose. POD publishers need to develop a list of contractural requirements that Amazon/BookSurge must meet before we sign with them. Here's a short list off the top of my head:
!. Since Amazon is doing the printing, selling and shipping, Amazon must take care of all damaged returns and clearly state that on the detail page for the book. That means that for BookSurge books, publishers can clearly state inside the book that Amazon must be contacted for all returns, that the publisher has no responsibility and no liability. I suspect this is something Amazon's upper execs haven't considered.
2. Amazon must offer high-quality return services, as high quality as we might like to offer. Having a 800 number manned by humans, paying postage both ways, and promising to get a new copy to the customer within two weeks. Given the reputed dismal quality of BookSurge, that could get pricey for Amazon.
3. Remember, we're happy with the current arrangement and can find no benefit for ourselves in these changes. Amazon must use carrots rather than sticks. BookSurge must take book files in the same format as Lightning Source and match or better their prices. That'll eliminate the considerable conversion costs. Personally, I'd add another. If Amazon has 5% of the book sales in this country, their prices to put our books on their system must be 5% of LSI. We should not have to pay as much to reach 5% of the market as we pay to reach 95%. Reporters a likely to find that sort of fairness argument compelling.
4. Since BookSurge can't print in the same sizes and formats as Lightning, Amazon must continue to sell all books in those sizes and formats, getting them from Lightning, until BookSurge offers that size and format. It must also sell titles from Lightning in any country BookSurge doesn't print (apparently in the UK).
5. This is the most important. With Amazon in complete control of a book's publication chain, they must open up ALL their books to any pod publisher who asks, immediately, completely, and without charge. Remember, with the current scheme involving Lightning, Ingram, and an independent bookstore, we have multiple checks on what's printed and sold. With Amazon doing it all, they could very easily print 1000 copies, but pay us for only 800. How would we know? We wouldn't. Can we trust Amazon? Of course not! We know they're scum. If they protest, we can reply, "What do you have to hide?"
6. So we know when to invoke #5, they must report to us all sales of our titles weekly, detailing how many books, when they were sold (to the minute), and where they were shipped down to the zip code. That would let pod publisher make test sales or get friends to forward receipts for purchases they make. If a sale doesn't show up on the weekly report, the contract would allow us go into their accounting and tracking system to find out why. Any missed sale would incur a substantial penalty, perhaps 100 times the loss plus all costs.
Will Amazon agree to all that? Almost certainly not. But by refusing, Amazon will demonstrate that this isn't about customer service nor is it about integrity. We take the moral high ground and leave them fuming and sputtering.
I emphasize yet again, if we don't take charge of this dispute, Amazon will stay in charge and slowly wear us down, a little this year, a bit more the next. We need to act, we need to act now, and we need to act together. When BookSurge reps call, we need to be able to say, "Have you agreed to the contract yet?" If they say no, then the conversation is over. Put the onus on them to meet our demands. If we don't this, they what is happening now is only the beginning our our troubles with Amazon.
Appeasement will not work. Every bit of meat we feed to the beast will just make it bigger and make it want more.
Many people are willing to cheap ugg boots spend hundreds and even thousands of dollars each year only to conceal or hide the stretch mark arisen on their bodies. There are a lot more products available on the market that claim to work better than ones that indeed do. It is true that people will try just buy ugg boots about anything, whether it is a stretch mark cream or gel, to achieve the desired look that they want. For this reason, this industry has become a business of multi-million dollar profitable.
Michael Jordan and air jordan shoes experiences over the past 20 years of ups and downs have been reflected by The pattern on the uppers.Basketball legend have been create by Michael Jordan, air jordan will continue to perfect interpretation of the legendary. Become the Michael Jordan-like figure, is the dream of all Americans.
These were runescape accounts worrisome times. It had not been so long before, during a
runescape money Vatican meeting with an aide to the pope’s secretary of state, that William Casey left with a final word of caution.
Again came the blank of a pause: the clock struck eight strokes. It aroused him; he uncrossed his legs, sat erect, turned to mewow goldaround the duskywow goldThey went about poking sticks into the sandwow gold you with your alarms prevent me from workingwow goldwow goldYou will find them both here, and can make your farewells in personwow goldwow goldThen of what other scourge are you afraidwow goldThey were perfectly round white things a trifle smaller than an English walnutwow gold Louis XVIII. remained alone, and turning his eyes on his half-opened Horace, muttered, "Justum et tenacem propositi virum
Maybe it is truewow gold that we do not knowworld of warcraft gold what we have got until wecheap wow gold lose it,but it is alsowow power leveling true that we do notwow powerleveling know what we have beenbuy wow gold missing until it arrives.final fantasy gilGiving someone all cheap ffxi gilyour love is never an ffxi gilassurance that they will maplestory Mesoslove you back .DoMaple Story meso not expect love in return;LOTRO Goldjust wait for it LOTR Goldto grow in their heart;lord of the rings goldbut if it does not be content dofus kamasit grew in yours.It take an hour tokamas dofus like someone,and a day to love someone ,but it takes a lifetime to forget someone .Do not rely on one's appearance;it can deceive.Do not rely on wealth; even that fades runescape goldaway .Rely on someone who makes you smile ; becauce it takes runescape moneyonly a smile to make a dark day seem bright.There arers money moments in life when you miss someone so much that you just want to pick them from your dreams and hug them.Dream what you want to dream ; go where you want to go ;EverQuest 2 gold be what you want to be ,eq2 plat because you have only one life .flyff penya and one chance to do all the things you want to do .May you have enough happiness to make you sweet , enough trials to make you strong , enough sorrow toflyff hack penya keep you human , enough hope flyff moneyto make you happy , always put yourself in others' shoes . If you feel that it hurts you , it probably hurts the other person , too ......
At the expiration of a year the governor was transferred; he had obtained charge of the fortress at Ham.dofus kamaskamas dofusffxi gilfinal fantasy xi gilbuy ffxi gilmaple story mesosmaplestory mesosdofus kamaskamas dofusbuy wow goldcheap wow gold which seemed themselves sensible of the heat. Thousands of grasshoppers, hidden in the bushesworld of warcraft golddiablo 2 cd keydiablo 2 cd keyrunescape goldrunescape moneydofus kamaskamas dofusdofus kamaskamas dofuseverquest 2 goldeq2 platHe took with him several of his subordinates, and amongst them Dants' jailer.
The small and angular head of this man, his white hair and thick gray mustaches, caused him to be easily recognized by Baptistinwow power levelingwow powerlevelingwow levelingwow power levelingwow powerlevelingIn a word, the island was inhabited, yet Edmond felt himself alone, guided by the hand of Godwow levelingfinal fantasy xi gilbuy ffxi gilgil ffxiffxi gildofus kamaskamas dofusHe felt an indescribable sensation somewhat akin to dread--that dread of the daylight which even in the desert makes us fear we are watched and observedffxi gilfinal fantasy xi gilcheap ffxi gilffxi cheap gilrunescape goldrunescape moneywho had received an exact description of the expected visitor, and who was awaiting him in the hall. Therefore
8.08LWelcome to wow power leveling,You can buy wow gold,buy wow gold power leveling website!cheap wow gold.
Anarchy credits in which world have one feature. First of all, realize the Anarchy Online credits is useful to the each new player. You only play with others and buy AO credits can get happy from the game, you may found the Anarchy online gold. However, Anarchy gold can also save a lot your time.
I can get Tales Of Pirates gold cheaply,
Yesterday i bought Tales Of Pirates moneyfor my brother. i hope him like it.
i will give cheap Tales Of Pirates gold to him as birthday present. I sually buy Tales Of Pirates Gold and keep it in my store.
i can get priston tale Gold cheaply,
Yesterday i bought priston tale Money for my brother.
i hope him like it. i willbuy priston tale Gold to him
as birthday present. i like the cheap priston tale Gold very much.
In the game the [url=http://www.gamekoo.com/product/Metin2_Yang.html]Metin2 gold[/url] id very important ,many players need the [url=http://www.gamekoo.com/product/Metin2_Yang.html]Metin2 yang[/url] ,they want to spend a little money to buy much [url=http://www.gamekoo.com/product/Metin2_Yang.html]Cheap metin2 yang[/url] ,but now the [url=http://www.gamekoo.com/product/Metin2_Yang.html]Cheap metin2 gold[/url] is very expensive,so they do not know how to [url=http://www.gamekoo.com/product/Metin2_Yang.html]Buy metin2 gold[/url].
In the game the Metin2 gold id very important,many players need the Metin2 yang,they want to spend a little money to buy much Cheap metin2 yang,but now the Cheap metin2 gold is very expensive ,so they do not know how to Buy metin2 gold.
If some player wants to buy the requirement, he must have to buy Daoc Gold first by himself. Daoc Plat has helped me finish many things. Because when some one player gains a little cheap Dark Age of Camelot Palt, he needs to hand in a leader of this team. They have the capability of jumping over obstacles that are higher than their height Dark Age of Camelot Gold, and have the strength to handle weapons which you can gain from a little Daoc Platinum that are bigger than themselves to make up for their small physiques.
If you like playing the game which needs use rappelz rupees, you will borrow rappelz gold from you friends, and also you can buy rupees, and than if you get rappelz money, you can use cheap rappelz rupees to play.
Chris Brown Fans React To His Sentencing8.27Cwow gold,cheap wow gold,wow power levelingChris Brown and Rihanna Had a History of Violence,wow gold,buy wow gold,wow power leveling.Chris Brown Fans React To His Sentencingwow gold,cheap wow gold,wow power leveling.
出会い系 出会い系 出会い系 出会い系 出会い系 出会い系 出会い系 出会い系 出会い系 出会い系 出会い系 出会い系 出会い系 出会い系 出会い系 出会い系 出会い系 出会い系 出会い系 出会い系 出会い系 出会い系 出会い系 出会い系 出会い系 出会い系 出会い系 出会い系 出会い系 出会い系 出会い系 出会い系 出会い系 出会い系 セフレ セフレ セフレ セックスフレンド セックスフレンド セックスフレンド 人妻 人妻 人妻 出会い系 無料 出会い系 無料 出会い系サイト メル友 競馬予想 競馬予想 競馬予想 競馬予想 競馬予想 競馬予想 競馬予想 競馬予想 競馬予想 競馬予想 競馬予想 競馬予想 競馬予想 競馬予想 競馬予想 競馬予想 競馬予想 競馬予想 競馬予想 競馬予想
デリヘル デリヘル デリヘル デリヘル デリヘル デリヘル デリヘル 新宿 デリヘル セフレ デリヘル デリヘル デリヘル デリヘル デリヘル デリヘル デリヘル デリヘル デリヘル デリヘル デリヘル デリヘル デリヘル デリヘル デリヘル デリヘル デリヘル デリヘル デリヘル デリヘル デリヘル デリヘル デリヘル デリヘル デリヘル デリヘル 渋谷 デリヘル デリヘル デリヘル デリヘル デリヘル 出会い 出会い 出会い 出会い 出会い 完全無料 出会い 完全無料 出会い 無料 出会い系
出逢い 無料 出逢い 掲示板 出合い系サイト 出会い 掲示板 出会い ランキング 出会い系サイト 無料 出会 人妻 出会い系 出会い系 不倫 出会 無料 無料 出会 無料 出会 出会 無料 出会 無料 出会 無料 無料 出会 無料 出会 完全無料 出会 赤坂 バー 風俗 風俗 風俗 風俗 風俗 風俗 風俗 風俗 風俗 風俗 風俗 風俗 風俗 渋谷 風俗 風俗 渋谷 風俗 池袋 キャバ嬢 0930 風俗
ugg boots sale
ugg boots sale
uggs
ugg boots
ugg boots sale
ugg boots sale
chi flat iron
chi hair straightener
air jordan shoes
nike dunk sb
DS Lite
DS Lite Console
ds flash card
nds flash card
ds dstt card
dstt card
ds r4
r4 card
ez flash ds lite
ez card ds
ds ez
ds edge
edge flash
ds crystal
n5 card
ds lite n5
m3 flash
m3 card
ds card reader
Micro SD card
Post a Comment